I love all this back-and-forth stuff. Here's Philip Klinkner's response to Bill Bishop and Bob Cushing, who responded earlier to Klinkner's article on their Great Divide series. Got all that?

Actually, as Klinkner noted in my comments, this is a longer version of that Gadflyer article, with charts and data. His response to Bishop and Cushing is forthcoming.

UPDATE: Here's Klinkner's response to Bishop (Word doc), which he emailed to me this morning.