June 06, 2005
An exception for TXI?

I've written about the cement plants in Midlothian before (see here and here for recent entries). Today I got the following press release:


(DALLAS) --- While the Dallas-Ft. Worth area struggles to find a way to reduce smog, the state environmental agency cut a backroom deal with TXI Operations, L.P., a Midlothian cement plant, to shut down its pollution control technology. The result will significantly increase emissions of toxic and smog forming pollutants. Outraged parents and environmental groups demand the state agency protect people over profits. A hearing to determine which is more important will be held June 7, 2005, City Council Chambers, 401 South Rogers Street, Waxahachie, Texas 75165. Parents and environmental groups will hold a press conference at 9 AM before the hearing.

"TXI thinks it is above the law," said Wendi Hammond, Blue Skies Alliance. "Even President George Bush's EPA has said TXI's request cannot be issued, but our state environmental agency is again caving to industry pressure while sacrificing the health of our children. Once again, it will be up to parents and environmental groups to ensure our environmental laws are enforced and our children protected."

"TXI's greed has gotten out of hand. Although TXI has enjoyed record profits while successfully operating the pollution controls, TXI claims the technology costs too much to operate because of increased natural gas prices," said Rebecca Bornhorst, Downwinders At Risk. "Everybody is dealing with fuel price increases, including other industries. It's a fact of life. But TXI thinks rules that apply to everyone else shouldn't apply to them."

TXI filed its application before Ellis County was reclassified as nonattainment for violating the Clean Air Act. Cost is no longer an excuse under the new classification. The shut down would result in significant increase of toxic emissions year round, including an almost 12% increase of smog forming emissions during the ozone season.

More information on the hearing and a press conference beforehand can be found at the Blue Skies Alliance and at the Midlothian Family Network. There's also a blog dedicated to TXI issues, but it unfortunately isn't updated all that often. Anyway, if you're in the area, check it out.

I'll see if there's any press coverage on this tomorrow - right now, a Google news search on "TXI" is pretty barren. Well, not completely. Look who's coming to Ellis County:


Erin Brockovich, an environmental crusader made famous by the movie that bears her name, is coming to Ellis County.

Brockovich and a team of lawyers are researching the county's industrial pollution to determine whether it is affecting people's health.

If so, they say, they will sue the operators of cement kilns and other industries in Midlothian.

The group plans to schedule a public meeting next month in Midlothian to discuss its research and gauge interest in a suit, said Jim Ross, an Arlington lawyer who is working with Brockovich.

Brockovich said she is coming "to educate and make the community aware of the facts."

"We don't want to create a community scare. But if I can come in and create greater awareness of the issues, that's a giant part of my job."

[...]

State health statistics show that rates of cancer and chronic lower respiratory disease per 100,000 residents in Ellis County exceeded the state rates in 2002 the latest year for which statistics are available from the Texas Department of State Health Services.

But so did the rates of those illnesses in other counties in North Texas, according to the statistics.

Kaufman County has a higher overall cancer rate than Ellis; five other area counties have higher rates of respiratory disease, with Denton County recording the highest.

Only the lung cancer rate in Ellis County exceeded the rates in the other metroplex counties in 2002.

The overall birth defect rate in Ellis County exceeded the state rate per 10,000 live births in 2001, the latest year for which statistics are available. But Collin, Dallas, Denton and Tarrant counties all exceeded Ellis County's rate.

However, several studies in the past decade have suggested that toxic pollution affects the health of Ellis County residents, say Ross, the lawyer working with Brockovich, and others.

One is a 1995 study led by Marvin Legator, an environmental toxicologist at the University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston.

Legator's study found three times more respiratory illnesses in Midlothian home to most of the county's industries than in Waxahachie a few miles away.

It also found that the rate of cancer deaths in Ellis County was consistently higher than the rate in neighboring Tarrant County.

A year later, researchers at the University of Michigan ripped a state health-risk assessment that determined TXI's cement-kiln emissions posed little health risk.

The study, commissioned by the American Lung Association and the regional environmental group Downwinders at Risk, said the state's scientific approach was severely flawed and its conclusions unfounded.

That same year, Peter Langlois, a senior epidemiologist with the Texas Department of Health, published a study that found an unusually high number of babies in Ellis County born with Down syndrome.


That story is over a week old, so I assume she's already there. Obviously, this is something to keep an eye on. Stay tuned.

Posted by Charles Kuffner on June 06, 2005 to The great state of Texas | TrackBack
Comments

Dude, if Julie Roberts comes to town, maybe TCEQ will actually do something. Short of that, pollunters have bought Texas Republicans and they wouldn't mind showing you the recipt.

Another great reason for people to STOP VOTING FOR REPUBLICANS!

Posted by: Red Dog on June 6, 2005 4:17 PM

What about the employees there. I know many people, more than 10 less than 1000 who have worked there for over 20yrs without illness. So are these people superhuman or is TXI following the rules and people are looking for a quick payday.

Posted by: unknown on June 14, 2005 7:12 AM

This is in reference to your June 03, 2005 posting titled �An Exception for TXI?� These are the true facts that probably were not shared with you at the time of your inquiry.

Ellis County birth defect data ranking for 2002
Year 2002 birth defect rates for the following counties: http://soupfin.tdh.state.tx.us/defectc06.htm
Ellis 651.7
Collin 537.9
Tarrant 460.3
Denton 445.2
Dallas 437.7
Texas 366.0

Cumulative Public Health Region 3 1999 - 2003
North Central Texas� Public Health Region 3, which includes Dallas, Tarrant, Ellis and 16 other surrounding counties is experiencing the highest rate of overall birth defects of all the eleven Texas Public Health Regions. http://www.dshs.state.tx.us/birthdefects/Data/annl99-03.shtm. According to the Texas State Health Department this birth defect rate is determined to be statistically significantly higher than among all Texas resident deliveries during 1999-2003.
Microcephaly , hypospadias or epispadias, obstructive genitourinary defect , craniosynostosis, and total birth dects are determined to be statistically significantly higher in Public Health Region 3 than among all Texas resident deliveries during 1999-2003
Total birth defects
Region 3, unadjusted: 431.34 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 425.54-437.15)
Region 3, adjusted: 426.30 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 420.49-432.10)
Texas: 360.70 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 357.94-363.45)
Interpretation: Total birth defects remained statistically significantly higher in Region 3 than in Texas after adjustment for maternal race/ethnicity and age efects to be statistically significantly higher in Region 3 than Texas overall.


ELLIS COUNTY cumulative 199-2003
After adjusting for maternal race/ethnic group and maternal age group, total birth defects and craniosynostosis were statistically significantly higher among deliveries to residents of Ellis County than among all Texas resident deliveries during 1999-2003.

Craniosynostosis
Ellis County, unadjusted: 14.16 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 7.54-24.21)
Ellis County, adjusted: 15.26 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 5.71-24.82)
Texas: 4.23 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 3.93-4.53)
Interpretation: Craniosynostosis remained statistically significantly higher in Ellis County than in Texas after adjustment for maternal race/ethnicity and age.
Total birth defects
Ellis County, unadjusted: 498.75 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 453.07-544.43)
Ellis County, adjusted: 483.66 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 433.53-533.78)
Texas: 360.70 per 10,000 live births (95% CI 357.94-363.45)
Interpretation: Total birth defects remained statistically significantly higher in Ellis County than in Texas after adjustment for maternal race/ethnicity and age.

(Note Ellis County birth defect rate for period 1999-2003 is even higher the Public Health Region 3).

Posted by: Sal Mier on January 21, 2007 3:55 PM