More on those fake pamphlets

Some good reporting out there.

A Travis County judge is set to hear arguments Tuesday in a case that could provide the first legal pathway toward identifying who is behind controversial transgender mailers sent to homes across Texas.

The Transgender Education Network of Texas, known as TENT, says its name and photographs were used without permission in the mailers. The organization is seeking pre-lawsuit discovery, a legal process that allows potential plaintiffs to gather information before filing a lawsuit.

The effort comes as questions continue to swirl around who is behind the mailers.

A CBS News Texas I-Team investigation found the name listed on the flyer’s return address traces back to a Wyoming limited liability company, while a postal permit printed on the mailer is linked to an Illinois printing company.

As CBS News Texas first reported, the U.S. Postal Service identified the permit holder as Three Z Printing. However, a postal permit alone does not establish who created or paid for the mailers. It remains unclear what role, if any, the company played beyond the use of its permit.

Three Z Printing is owned by Bill Zerrusen and his three sons, including Matt Zerrusen, who lives in North Texas. CBS News Texas contacted the company and members of the Zerrusen family on Friday, but had not received a response as of Monday, Oct. 26.

[…]

Tuesday’s hearing is not expected to determine who sent the flyers or whether any laws were broken. TENT is asking a judge to allow its attorneys to question the Wyoming LLC named on the mailer, as well as a text-messaging company linked to messages that also used TENT’s name and directed recipients to the organization’s website.

See here for the background. WFAA has also done some deep digging.

The Transgender Education Network of Texas, known as TENT, filed a petition last week asking the court for permission to question representatives of two companies it believes may help identify those responsible for the communications.

The filing is known as a Rule 202 petition, a legal procedure that allows someone to obtain testimony before filing a lawsuit to investigate whether there are grounds for legal action.

TENT is seeking information from Infobip LLC, a telecommunications company connected to the phone numbers used to send unsolicited text messages, and Texas Transgender Student Union LLC, a newly registered company registered in Wyoming, whose name appeared on political mailers sent to Texas households.

TENT says it had nothing to do with either the texts or the mailers, which used its name, website and images without permission. The text messages, sent Oct. 12 and 13, directed recipients to TENT’s website for information about gender-affirming care in Texas and resources for transgender students, including guidance on school bathrooms.

In its court filing, TENT alleges the communications were part of an effort to mislead voters and damage the organization’s reputation.

“The identity of the organizations and/or individuals behind the Messages and Mailer are opaque,” the petition states.

The organization says the communications have led to threats against its staff and volunteers, forcing it to shut down its website, suspend public events and spend money on additional security.

TENT wants to identify those responsible so it can determine whether to pursue a lawsuit and seek an emergency court order to stop further communications before Election Day.

“TENT has reached a dead end and needs pre-suit discovery to move forward,” the petition states.

[…]

According to the court filing, the mailers included actual photographs from TENT events, images of its merchandise, its logo and its “Trans Texas” branding.

The four-panel brochure, titled “Texas Trans & LGBTQ+ Student Resource Guide,” devoted its back panels entirely to TENT.

But mixed in with those materials was advice that TENT says it never created or authorized.

The brochure included guidance directed at minors about what to do “if your parents don’t support you,” discussed traveling “out of state” for “hormones or gender affirming care,” and raised the question, “What if I want to be emancipated?”

The petition says none of that content came from TENT, even though it appeared alongside the organization’s actual name, images and website.

TENT alleges the combination was intended to make parents believe the organization was reaching out to their children about sensitive subjects without parental consent.

The mailers were addressed to students in individual households. TENT’s attorneys believe the sender may have obtained a mailing list identifying families with school-age children.

TENT believes the text messages and mailers were part of the same coordinated campaign, although the identities of those responsible remain unknown.

[…]

In an Oct. 16 response included in the court filing, Infobip said it would not voluntarily disclose customer information without appropriate legal process.

In a statement to WFAA, Infobip said the company acted “solely as a provider of transmission services” and did not “author or originate the content of the messages in question.”

“To uphold its legal obligations to protect data confidentiality, Infobip’s legal team discloses information in response to all appropriate legal requests/orders,” the statement said. “Upon becoming aware of the issue, we took immediate action. We have suspended the traffic in question and are actively monitoring the situation to prevent further occurrences.”

The company’s statement said they are “in active contact and cooperating with TENT’s lawyer on this matter.”

A company spokesman said Infobip’s legal team will attend the hearing remotely.

TENT’s attorneys also sent a cease-and-desist letter to Texas Transgender Student Union LLC, demanding that it identify the people responsible for the company and the mailers. According to the petition, the organization had not received a response when the court action was filed in Travis County.

The petition asks the judge to authorize depositions of representatives of both companies as early as Thursday and Friday.

Both stations sent reporters to Sheridan, Wyoming, in search of more information on where Texas Transgender Student Union LLC was registered. You should click over to each to see what they found out. I wrote this before there was any reporting on yesterday’s hearing, I’ll update if there are stories on that. I’m rooting for TENT to get a favorable ruling and begin deposing these assholes as soon as possible. The Current, the Observer, TPR, and Daily Kos have more.

UPDATE: Good.

A judge in Austin ruled Tuesday that a transgender advocacy group can proceed with its legal effort to uncover who is behind the mysterious campaign of text messages and mailers that have gone out ahead of the midterm elections purporting to represent transgender students.

During a preliminary court hearing, a lawyer for the group, Transgender Education Network of Texas, or TENT, said it has the right to know who is behind the effort because they used its logo and other branding against its will. The information, she said, is designed to give voters the false impresssion that TENT was trying to bypass parents and help young people access gender-affirming care.

“Somebody has been impersonating our client and sending out millions of unauthorized text messages and mailers to voters across Texas, intentionally creating confusion for voters and strife, and so we are very concerned that this could continue before the election,” attorney Mimi Marziani said after the hearing. “And we need to find out who’s responsible so that we can protect our clients and their rights.”

Chris Hilton, the attorney representing the newly-created shadow group behind the campaign, Texas Transgender Student Union, said it was engaging in speech protected by the First Amendment, even if had used branding from the other organization.

“Nothing here constitutes a violation of civil or criminal law,” Hilton told Judge Jan Soifer of the 345th Civil District Court of Travis County. “The first Amendment and Texas law do not bend for speech that is unpopular.”

Hilton said he intends to appeal the ruling that would lead to the naming of his client or clients who were behind the messaging.

[…]

Soifer told the lawyers they should try to work out an agreement on how the names of the people behind the mailings should be made public. Marziani and a lawyer who attended the hearing remotely representing Infobip, a communications company that sent the texts from TTSU, were expected to submit a proposed order to the judge by Wednesday.

A good start. Here’s hoping for a good appellate ruling as well.

Related Posts:

This entry was posted in Election 2026 and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to More on those fake pamphlets

  1. Joel says:

    It drives me crazy that they can gum up the process with such risible arguments. Falsely misrepresenting yourself as something you are not is not protected 1st amendment political speech. The question, if there is one, is whether this rises to the level of fraudulent misrepresentation.

  2. policywonqueria says:

    Without having seen the pleadings it may be premature to judge the merits of the lawsuit.

    That said, how does a lawsuit on this type of grievance not fail on standing grounds? The plaintiff organization is not a political party, so it can’t even lose a single vote as a result of the machinations. Nor did it pay for the postage or the printing.

    So, where are the damages? Indeed, it would appear that they are getting free publicity for their cause (assuming crimes and/or atrocities are not falsely attributed to them).

    You have to understand that the Texas Supreme Court has imported federal article III jurisprudence into Texas litigation practice in defiance of the Texas constitution, and uses it as it sees fit to nix lawsuits and claims in accordance with their ideological priors.
    The standing doctrine is binding on all lower courts and supposed to be applied even if not adverse party raises it in a motion. It can even be done later on appeal even though other types of defects or errors are waived if not properly objected to and made part of the record.

    This particular lawsuit appears to be a good candidate for jurisdictional dismissal.

    Even if the BLUE WAVE materializes and benefits the supreme court candidate that complains about having to walk 2 miles to dad’s house because her Mom abandoned her at a gas station, it won’t be enough to change the Texas version of the standing doctrine. Only 4 seats are up for election in this round and the 9 incumbents are all GOP, most of them filtered for ideological acceptability, if not purity, by Governor Abbott.

    The Senate race is a different story as the one seat at stake in Texas may be critical. Ditto for the Governor’s race, albeit for different reasons: Senate control based on majority; governorship all-or-nothing. Notably, the “all” includes the power to fill judicial vacancies, including the one left behind by the sitting appellate justices running for spots on the SCOTX should they succeed (as noted in at least one editorial endorsement by a major Texas newspaper).

    Speaking of gas stations, Gina H. looks great in Houston Chronicle Sunday edition pic, but also a bit forlorn. Where are the crowds? – Not in the picture. Still, the choice of situs is clever because the shot includes the digital per-gallon price display. That’s something that folks do care about, though “everday Texans” may not make the connection to certain foreign policies of the incumbent regime and the power of the U.S. Congress to stop it.

    Okay, so this is a Rule 202 action to investigate only, at this point.

    Still, if an actual lawsuit against the imposter(s) would be barred by lack of standing, is there enough basis to seek discovery? Arguably so because the organization in question should be able to control its own communications strategy, and should at least be entitled known who is messing with them even if no actual damages can be shown that would satisfy article III.

    Keywords: standing doctrine, political lawfare, culture war, politics by other means, false-flag operations

  3. Kenneth J Fair says:

    Of course they have standing. As stated in the story above, “The organization says the communications have led to threats against its staff and volunteers, forcing it to shut down its website, suspend public events and spend money on additional security.” That’s more than sufficient of an injury-in-fact to support standing. Depending on what’s in the mailers and what TENT’s positions are, the allegations could support causes of action for defamation or false light invasion of privacy, as well as violations of the Lanham Act and/or the Texas Trademark Act.

    It is possible that this Texas Supreme Court would bend the standing rules, but I kinda doubt it. That gun kicks and shoots.

  4. Kenneth J Fair says:

    Oh, and agreed with Joel—the idea that this is protected First Amendment speech is laughable. It would be one thing if they had sent out a mailer condemning TENT. It’s another thing entirely to mislead people into thinking the mailer is from TENT.

  5. policywonqueria says:

    THE KING (AND HIS AGENTS) CAN DO NO WRONG

    How and why Texas Citizens are deprived of Standing to Complaint about their government in court.

    Folks:

    As recently as today, the Mini-SCOTX overruled a challenge to the Texas immunity and standing doctrines, pointing out that it is an intermediate court bound to follow SCOTX.

    This is, of course, correct in a hierarchical judicial system, but that doesn’t make it right.

    No incumbent Abbott-selected member (they are all on the 2026 ballot) saw fit to write separately to call into question these anti-citizen doctrines, not to mention calling for them to be overruled by the higher court: The only court that can ditch or modify these oppressive “common law” precedents: It’s own.

    WHAT THE SCOTX HAS WROUGHT

    The Texas Supreme Court (4 positions of 9 now up for grabs) took it up on itself — long before the rise of MAGA and the no-kings protests — to render the Bill of Rights of the Texas constitution inoperative and irrelevant by giving the state and government entities
    immunity from suit and liability by fiat.

    These are judge-made rulings that systemically alter the relationship of citizenry and government to aggrandize the power of the state and state officials. It allows agents of the state to escape responsiblity for their actions regardless of whether they are elected or not.

    Never mind that the very purpose of the Bill of Rights is to protect Texans from abusive state government, and to constrain its power of this officials and agents.

    NO STANDING TO SQUEAL & SEEK A JUDICIAL REMEDY

    As if that weren’t bad enough, the same SCOTX more recently has adopted the restrictive federal test for standing to sue, which applies to federal courts OF LIMITED JURISDICTION (under Article III of the U.S. Constitution) whereas Texas district courts are courts of GENERAL JURISDICTION. — Not any more, thanks to judicial fiat issued from the top.

    Notable quote from the government brief in yesterday’s case:

    “The sole fact alleged that Appellant is a citizen with rights under the Texas and U.S. constitutions does not negate the application of governmental immunity.”

    In other words, in our system of government, the citizen is a nobody in court because the state agents are above the law and immunized to legal action against them. They are, in effect, out of control.

    Additionally, in today’s case, the Mini-SCOTX denied the citizen/litigant standing as a voter to challenge election procedures. See above argument that the transgender group lacking standing.

    The entire docket, including the opinion, is here:
    https://search.txcourts.gov/Case.aspx?cn=15-26-00021-CV&coa=coa15

    NOT ALL UNREPRESENTED LITIGANTS ARE INTELLECTUALLY INFERIOR

    This is also one of those cases where a pro se litigant did an excellent job articulating the proper legal arguments, with citations to pertinent authorities (even though the formatting betrays amateurship). She got crushed anyhow, but at least the Fifteenth Court of Appeals issued an opinion that reiterates the infamous basis for its non-merits disposition for everyone to see. Don’t expect the Texas Tribune to delve that deep. And as for appellate attorneys, it’s generally futile to challenge immunity rulings because they know that they are guaranteed to lose. If they have any ethics, they would have their clients know that they will be wasting their money on fees.

    TEXAS GOVERNMENT ENTITIES CAN’T BE SUED BECAUSE OF THE SCOTX

    What you can see once more is that we have de facto judicial supremacy in Texas, which is also de jure, based on the state supreme court’s own self-serving pronouncements, which have the force of law.

    Time and again, the same court cites itself as legal authority, and all lower courts are duty-bound to regurgitate the mantra that you can’t sue the state because the state is the state and you are just a lowly subject (though they don’t call you that).

    The state defendant(s) will routinely file a “plea to the jurisdiction” (motion to dismiss) blaming you, the citizen-wretch, for not having overcome the defendant’s immunity. Everyone knows there is no way around it, and the Mini-SCOTX is well aware too, and therefore duly denies an opportunity to replead. But they fault you anyhow.

    It just cannot be done. The immunity is so airtight.

    If the 4 Democrats win their high-court contests, they might get their first chance to weigh in on at least two of the justiciability doctrines the court has developed and refined to suppress citizen complaints and eschew the merits of those complaints, even – notably – complaints of violations of the constitution or lesser laws: The standing doctrine, which they appropriated from the federal system, and the Republican reincarnation of The-King-No-Wrong-Can-Do doctrine inherited from and dating back to East-Coast colonial times (Texas was, after all, part of Spain, later Mexico, and only much later imported the so-called common law deriving from the English courts).

    WHEN THE KING MESSES WITH ELECTIONS

    The ultimate indignity in a case like is that sovereign immunity is invoked to preclude a merits decision on a legal dispute relating to the most important instrument of people’s control over their non-monarchical government: elections and how they are properly and faithfully administered to pick worthy rulers that represent the will of the people and acts in their interest. It gets slapped down in the name of “the Sovereign.”

    As if the people of Texas weren’t themselves the Sovereign in republic, following overthrow or emancipation from the King.

    Case cites:
    Kristen Plainsance v. Ken Paxton, No. 15-26-00152-CV
    Kristen Plainsance v. Montgomery County and its Elections’ Office, No. 15-26-00021-CV
    (Tex.App.- Austin [15th Dist.] Oct. 29, 2026, no pet. h.)

Comments are closed.